Publication Ethics

Introduction

Media Informasi uses the Committee of Publication Ethics (CoPE) as its reference on publication ethics. A ‘code of conduct’ which outlines desired behavior and obligations of members of the scientific profession is needed in the publication of an article in peer-reviewed journal. Such of a code of conduct attempts to optimize the advantages of science to society and the profession. The advancement of science necessitates the sharing of knowledge, even though this may sometimes forego any immediate personal advantage.

The publication of scientific research in journals is one of the fundamental ways in which Media Informasi serves the geography science communities. For this purpose, editors, reviewers, authors and publishers have to maintain the high ethical standard relating to the publication of manuscripts in the Media Informasi.

 

Editors

Editors have the following responsibilities:

  • To decide which of the articles submitted to the journal should be published. Editors are accountable and responsible for everything they publish.
  • To make a decision to accept or reject a manuscript for publication with reference only to the manuscript’s importance, originality and clarity, and its relevance to the journal.
  • To acknowledge receipt of submitted manuscripts and to ensure the fair, efficient and timely review process of submitted manuscripts.
  • To assess manuscripts for the intellectual subject matter disregarding race, gender, religious belief, sexual orientation, ethnic origin, citizenship, or political philosophy of the authors. 
  • To guarantee that submitted manuscripts are handled in a confidential conduct, with no details being disclosed to anyone, with the exception of the reviewers, without the permission of the author, until a decision has been taken as to whether the manuscript is to be published.
  • Not unveil any information about a submitted manuscript to anyone excluding the corresponding author, reviewers, potential reviewers, other editorial advisers, and the publisher, as appropriate.
  • Not to use for their own research, work reported in unpublished submitted articles.
  • To act in response to any suggestions of scientific misconduct or to convincing evidence that the main substance or conclusions of a published manuscript is mistaken, usually through consultation with the author. This may necessitate the publication of a formal withdrawal or amendment.
  • To determine rationally responsive measures when ethical objections have been presented concerning a submitted manuscript or published paper, in association with the publisher (or society).

 

Reviewers

Reviewers should:

  • Only agree to review manuscripts for which they have the subject expertise required to conduct an appropriate evaluation and which they can assess in a timely manner.
  • Acknowledge that peer review is a reciprocal effort and undertake to conduct their fair share of reviewing and in a timely manner.
  • Be objective and constructive in their reviews, abstaining from being hostile and from making offensive personal remarks.
  • Have a non-influenced review, neither by the author’s nationality, religious nor political beliefs’ of the author, gender nor other characteristics of the authors, nor by commercial considerations.
  • Treat any manuscripts received for review as confidential documents. They must not be shown to or discussed with others except as authorized by the editor.
  • Not use information obtained during the peer-review process for their own or any other person’s or organization’s advantage or to disadvantage or discredit others.
  • Recognize relevant published work that has not been referred by the authors. Any statement that an observation, derivation, or argument had been previously reported should be completed by pertinent reference.
  • State all possible conflicting interests, looking for recommendation from the journal if they are hesitant whether something constitutes a relevant interest.

 

Authors

Authors have the following responsibilities:

  • To present a report of the research that has been conducted in an ethical and responsible manner.
  • To present their results clearly, truthfully, and without fraudulent, misrepresentation or improper data manipulation.
  • To provide, if needed, the unprocessed data in connection with a paper for editorial review.
  • To ensure that the work they submitted is an original work. If the authors have used the work and/or words of others that this has been appropriately cited or referred. Plagiarism in all its forms comprises unethical publishing manners and is intolerable.
  • To describe their methods clearly and explicitly so that their findings can be confirmed by others.
  • Take collective responsibility for submitted and published work.
  • The authorship of research publications should precisely reveal individuals’ contributions to the work and its reporting.
  • To disclose in their manuscript any financial or other substantive conflict of interest that might be construed to influence the results or interpretation of their manuscript. All sources of financial support for the project should be disclosed.
  • To report without delay the journal editor or publisher if an author notices a major inaccuracy or erroneousness in his/her own published work. He/she has to collaborate with the editor to withdraw or correct the paper.

 

Authorship and Co-authorship

Authorship should be limited to individuals who have made substantial contributions to the research and manuscript. Authors should not list AI tools as an author or co-author, nor cite AI tools as an author. Authorship implies responsibilities and tasks that can only be attributed to and performed by humans. Authors must provide a declaration of their respective contributions during submission.

Any change in authorship after submission must be approved by all authors, supported by a written justification, and submitted to the editor for review. Changes after the final revision will only be considered under exceptional circumstances.

Gift, ghost, and honorary authorship are prohibited and may result in corrective action in accordance with COPE guidelines. Individuals who contributed to the work but do not meet authorship criteria should be acknowledged with their permission.

 

Publishers

Publishers should:

  • Define the relationship between publisher, editor and other parties in a contract.
  • Respect privacy (for example, for research participants, for authors, for reviewers).
  • Defend intellectual property and copyright.
  • Promote editorial independence.
  • Work with journal editors to:
  • Regulate journal policies appropriately and aspire to meet those policies, particularly with respect to: editorial independence; research ethics; authorship; clearness and honesty; peer review; appeals and complaints.
  • Inform journal policies to authors, readers, reviewers.
  • Evaluate journal policies periodically.
  • Preserve the integrity of the academic record.
  • Support the parties in charge for the investigation of suspected research and publication misconduct and, where possible, assist in the resolution of these problems.
  • Issue amendments, clarifications, and retractions.
  • Publish content on a timely basis.

Dealing with Misconduct

(Based on COPE's Ethical Guide on Misconduct)

  1. Plagiarism and Data Fabrication
    • Journals should have policies in place to detect and address plagiarism, data fabrication, and other forms of research misconduct.
    • Investigations should be conducted in a fair and transparent manner, and appropriate actions taken if misconduct is confirmed.
  2. Authorship Issues
    • Editors should ensure that authorship is based on substantial contributions to the research and that all authors have approved the final manuscript.
  3. Conflict Resolution
    • Journals should establish mechanisms for addressing disputes and conflicts related to publication ethics.
  4. Retractions and Corrections
    • If research misconduct or errors are discovered post-publication, journals should consider issuing retractions or corrections as appropriate.

These publication ethics guidelines based on COPE's principles should be integrated into the journal's policies and communicated clearly to all stakeholders, including editors, reviewers, and authors, to maintain the highest standards of academic publishing integrity.


Ethical Guidelines for Journal Publication

  1. Editorial Integrity and Responsibility
    • Editors must uphold the highest standards of integrity and impartiality in their roles.
    • Editorial decisions should be based solely on the merit and quality of the submitted work, without discrimination.
    • Avoid conflicts of interest, and declare them transparently when they exist.
    • Ensure that the peer review process is fair, unbiased, and confidential.
  2. Authorship and Author Responsibilities
    • Authors should provide accurate and complete information during manuscript submission.
    • All authors must have made a substantial contribution to the research and should be listed as co-authors.
    • Acknowledge the contributions of individuals who provided assistance but do not meet authorship criteria.
    • Avoid plagiarism, self-plagiarism, and duplication of content; properly cite and reference sources.
  3. Peer Review
    • Peer reviewers should be chosen based on their expertise and impartiality.
    • Reviewers should treat submitted manuscripts confidentially and refrain from using the information for personal gain.
    • Reviewers should provide constructive, fair, and timely feedback.
    • Report any ethical concerns, conflicts of interest, or suspicions of misconduct to the editor.
  4. Research Misconduct
    • Journal editors and reviewers should be vigilant in identifying and addressing research misconduct, including fabrication, falsification, and plagiarism.
    • Suspected misconduct should be thoroughly investigated following COPE's guidelines for handling such cases.
    • Transparently communicate the outcomes of investigations and, if necessary, issue corrections or retractions.
  5. Ethical Reporting and Transparency
    • Authors must accurately report their research methods, results, and interpretations.
    • Provide access to original data when requested by editors, reviewers, or readers.
    • Clearly disclose any potential conflicts of interest, funding sources, or competing interests.

      Post-publication Discussion

      Readers, researchers, and other stakeholders are encouraged to communicate any comments, concerns, or observations regarding published content to the editorial office. Constructive post-publication discussions may be submitted as letters to the editor or formal responses and may be considered for publication following editorial review.

      When errors, omissions, or inaccuracies are identified in published work, the editorial team will assess the matter and, where appropriate, publish a correction, erratum, or corrigendum linked to the original article to maintain the accuracy and integrity of the scholarly record.

      In cases involving suspected research misconduct, data falsification, plagiarism, or other ethical breaches, an investigation will be conducted in accordance with COPE guidelines and may involve consultation with authors, reviewers, and relevant institutions. Depending on the findings, appropriate actions may include the publication of a correction, an Expression of Concern, or a retraction.

      All post-publication notices will be made openly accessible to ensure transparency and to maintain the integrity, reliability, and credibility of the scholarly record. The editorial team is committed to addressing post-publication issues promptly, fairly, and transparently.


      Conflicts of Interest

      All participants in the publication process, including authors, reviewers, and editors, must disclose any actual or potential conflicts of interest that could affect the review, interpretation, or publication of a manuscript. Conflicts may be financial, personal, professional, institutional, or otherwise capable of influencing objectivity.

      Authors must disclose relevant conflicts of interest and funding sources at the time of submission. Reviewers should declare any competing interests and decline review assignments when impartiality cannot be maintained. Editors and editorial board members must recuse themselves from handling manuscripts where a conflict of interest exists.

      Failure to disclose relevant conflicts of interest may result in corrective actions, including the publication of an Expression of Concern, article retraction, or other measures consistent with COPE guidelines. Transparency in the disclosure of competing interests is essential to maintaining the integrity and credibility of the scholarly record.

      Plagiarism and Self-Plagiarism
    • Journal publications should have strict policies against plagiarism and self-plagiarism.
    • Editors should use plagiarism detection tools when necessary.
    • Authors must ensure that their work is original, properly cited, and does not violate copyright laws.

      Ethical Use of Human and Animal Subjects
    • Authors should adhere to ethical guidelines for research involving human or animal subjects, including obtaining informed consent and necessary approvals.
    • Editors should verify that studies comply with these guidelines before publication.

      Transparency in Corrections and Retractions

      Upon receiving a credible allegation of misconduct, the Editorial Board will conduct a preliminary assessment under the direction of the Chief Editor. Where concerns arise regarding the ability of the Editorial Board to conduct an impartial investigation, or where a conflict of interest is identified, the Chief Editor may recommend that the relevant faculty authorities establish an independent committee to investigate the matter. If the allegation is substantiated through the investigation process, the Chief Editor may take appropriate corrective measures, including but not limited to:

      1. publishing a correction (erratum or corrigendum),
      2. retracting the article,
      3. withdrawing the article, and/or
      4. removing an author from the authorship record where justified by the findings.

      The journal is committed to maintaining a professional, respectful, and constructive peer-review environment. Accordingly, reviewers' comments and editorial correspondence must not contain personal attacks, discriminatory remarks, or offensive language directed at authors. Editors and reviewers are expected to evaluate and critique the scholarly content of a submission rather than the individual researcher. Any correspondence containing inappropriate, abusive, or unprofessional statements may be edited or rejected by the Editorial Board.

      Review and Adoption of COPE Guidelines

      Journal editors, publishers, and editorial boards should regularly review and adopt COPE's ethical guidelines and best practices for journal publication.