A Comparative Analysis of the Quality of Islamic and Conventional Banks’ Asset Management in Indonesia

M. Shabri Abd. Majid, Said Musnadi, Indra Yadi Putra
(Submitted 28 November 2014)
(Published 28 June 2014)


This research empirically and comparatively examines the quality of conventional and Islamic banks’ asset management in Indonesia during the period 2009-2011. Four general conventional banks [i.e., Bank Mandiri Indonesia (BMI), Bank Rakyat Indonesia (BRI), Bank Central Asia (BCA), and Bank Nasional Indonesia (BNI)] and four Islamic banks (Bank Muamalat, Bank Syariah Mandiri, Bank Syariah Mega Indonesia, and Bank Syariah BRI) were, respectively, explored. Specifically, the purpose of this study is to compare the quality of the Islamic and conventional banks’ asset management with the CAMEL (capital, asset, management, earning, and liquidity) method. It also attempts to analyse the influences of the ROA (Return on Asset), TLTA (Total Loan to Total Assets), and OITL (Operating Income to Total Liabilities) on the quality of the banks’ asset management. The CAMEL method was used to evaluate the quality level of the banks’ asset management, while the multiple regression analysis was then adopted to explore the determinants of the quality of the banks’ asset management. The study documented that Bank Syariah BRI was the best performing bank, with the highest CAMEL score of 50.33, while Bank Mandiri Indonesia was the worst performer with the lowest CAMEL score of 26.33. As a group, the Islamic banks were found to have better rankings, i.e., positions 1, 2, 3, and 6, while the conventional banks were found in 4, 5, 7, and 8, respectively. The study proved that the Islamic banks have a better asset management quality compared to their conventional counterparts. The Islamic banks were also proved to be better able to withstand the risks, particularly the financing risk.      

Full Text: PDF

DOI: 10.22146/gamaijb.5463


Almilia, L.S., and W. Herdiningtyas. 2005. Analisis rasio CAMEL terhadap prediksi kondisi bermasalah pada lembaga perbankan periode 2000-2002. Jurnal Akuntansi dan Keuangan 7 (2): 1411-1428.

Angbazo, L. 1997. Commercial bank net interest margins, default risk, interest rate risk, and off balance sheet banking. Journal of Banking and Finance 21 (1): 55–87.

Arafat, M. Y., A. D. Buchdadi, and Suherman. 2011. Analysis of bank’s performance and efficiency in Indonesia. Social Science Research Network. Available at SSRN: http://ssrn.com/abstract=1805529.

Aryati, T., and S. Balafif. 2007. Analisis faktor yang mempengaruhi tingkat kesehatan bank dengan regresi Logit. Journal The Winners 8 (2): 111-125.

Athanasoglou, P. P., S. N. Brissimis, and M. D. Delis. 2008. Bank specific, industry specific and macroeconomic determinants of bank profitability. Journal of International Financial Markets, Institutions and Money 18 (2): 121–136.

Bank Indonesia (BI). 2007. Regulation No. 9/1/PBI/2007: The Rating System For Commercial Banks Based on Sharia Principles. Jakarta, Indonesia.

Beck, T., and R. Levine. 2004. Stock markets, banks, and growth: Panel evidence. Journal of Banking and Finance 28 (3): 423–442.

Berger, A. N. 1995. The relationship between capital and earnings in banking. Journal of Money, Credit and Banking 27 (2): 432–456.

Berger, A. N., G. A. Hanweck, and D. B. Humphrey. 1987. Competitive viability in banking: Scale scope and product mix economies. Journal of Monetary Economics 20 (3): 501–520.

Cetorelli, N., and M. Gambera. 2001. Banking market structure, financial dependence and growth: International evidence from industry data. Journal of Finance 56 (2): 617–648.

Chantapong, S. 2005. Comparative study of domestic and foreign bank performance in Thailand: The regression analysis. Economic Change and Restructuring 38 (1): 63–83.

DeYoung, R., and T. Rice. 2004. Non-interest income and financial performance at US commercial banks. Financial Review 39 (1): 101–27.

Guru, B. K., J. Staunton, and B. Balashanmugam. 2002. Determinants of commercial bank profitability in Malaysia. Working Paper. Multimedia University, Malaysia.

Hastuti, H., and I. Subaweh. 2008. Analisis kinerja kesehatan bank sebelum dan setelah arsitektur perbankkan Indonesia. Working Paper. Jurusan Akuntansi Fakultas Ekonomi Universitas Gunadarma.

Hazzi, O. A., and M. I. Al-Kalani. 2013. The financial performance analysis of Islamic and traditional banks: Evidence from Malaysia. European Journal of Economics, Finance and Administrative Sciences 57:133-144.

Hirtle, B. J., and K. J. Stiroh. 2007. The return to retail and the performance of US banks. Journal of Banking and Finance 31 (4): 1101–33.

Kosmidou, K., F. Pasiouras, and A. Tsaklanganos. 2007. Domestic and multinational determinants of foreign bank profits: The case of greek banks operating abroad. Journal of Multinational Financial Management 17 (1): 1–15.

Kosmidou, K., and C. Zopounidis. 2008. Measurement of bank performance in Greece. South Eastern Europe Journal of Economics 1: 79–95.

Kwan, S. H., 2003. Operating performance of banks among Asian economies: An international and time series comparison. Journal of Banking and Finance 27 (3): 471-489.

Lestari, V. D. 2009. Analisis tingkat kesehatan bank-bank pemerintah dengan menggunakan metode CAMEL dan analisis diskriminan periode 2006-2008. Skripsi. Universitas Gunadarma, Indonesia.

Levine, R. 1998. The legal environment, banks, and long run economic growth. Journal of Money, Credit and Banking 30 (3): 596–613.

Levine, R., and S. Zevros. 1998. Stock markets, banks, and economic growth. American Economic Review 88 (3): 537–58.

Nugraheni, S.R.W. 2011. Analisis Daya Tahan Perbankan Syariah Terhadap Fluktuasi Ekonomi di Indonesia. Skripsi. Institut Pertanian Bogor, Indonesia.

Pasiouras, F., and K. Kosmidou. 2007. Factors influencing the profitability of domestic and foreign commercial banks in the European Union. Research in International Business and Finance 21 (2): 222–37.

Rajan, R. G., and L. Zingales. 1998. Financial dependence and growth. American Economic Review 88 (3): 559–86.

Rubitoh. 2003. Penelitian perbandingan kinerja keuangan bank muamalat dengan bank konvesional (enam bank konvensional). Skripsi. Universitas Islam Indonesia.

Samad, A. 2004. Performance of interest-free Islamic bank vis-à-vis unterest based conventional bank of Bahrain. IIUM Journal of Economics and Management 12 (2): 115-129.

Stiroh, K. J., and A. Rumble. 2006. The dark side of diversification: The case of US financial holding companies. Journal of Banking and Finance 30 (8): 2131–61.

Sufian, F. 2009. Factors influencing bank profitability in a developing economy: Empirical evidence from Malaysia. Global Business Review 10 (2): 225–41.

Sufian, F., and R. R. Chong. 2008. Determinants of bank profitability in a developing economy: Empirical evidence from the Phillipines. Asian Academy of Management Journal of Accounting and Finance 4 (2): 91–112.

Swandari, F. 2002. Pengaruh perilaku risiko, kepemilikan institusi dan kinerja terhadap kebangkrutan bank umum di Indonesia. Jurnal Ekonomi dan Bisnis Indonesia 17 (4): 1-25.

To, M. H., and D. Tripe. 2002. Factors influencing the performance of foreign owned banks in New Zealand. Journal of International Financial Markets, Institutions and Money 12 (4–5): 341–57.

Veverita. 2011. Performance analysis of Indonesian Islamic and conventional banks. Social Science Research Network. Available at SSRN: http://ssrn.com/abstract=1868938.

Williams, B. 2003. Domestic and international determinants of bank profits: Foreign banks in Australia. Journal of Banking and Finance 27 (6): 1185–210.

Wulandari, N. 2004. Keunggulan komparatif bank syariah. Suara Merdeka. Indonesia.

Yoon, I-H. 2006. Financial statement analysis for differentiating between failed and surviving merchant banks. Institute of East and West Studies, Yonsei University (Institute of East and West Studies) 18 (2): 131-160.


  • There are currently no refbacks.

Copyright (c)