Failures in Academic Research Assessing the Frequenting of Predatory Journals by Some Nigerian Academics
Bashir Bello(1*), Fadeyi Taofiq James(2)
(1) Department of Sociology, Federal University Gusau, Nigeria
(2) Department of Political Science, Federal University Gusau, Nigeria
(*) Corresponding Author
Abstract
Academic progress relies on integrity, and researchers must uphold rigorous standards to ensure knowledge advancement and informed decision-making. However, this foundation is threatened by the proliferation of predatory journals, which exploit the pressure to publish and undermine the credibility of scholarly work. For Nigerian academics, this challenge is compounded by limited awareness, institutional pressures, and scarce access to reputable outlets. This study investigates why Nigerian academics frequent predatory journals, exploring their motivations, consequences for research quality, and implications of this practice. Using an exploratory qualitative research design, the study collected data through Key Informant Interviews (KIIs) with selected academics at the Federal University Gusau, Zamfara State, Nigeria. Data generated from the interview were transcribed, and patterns were identified and organized according to the objectives of the research. The data were analyzed through enumeration, categorization, and thematic analysis. The results show that a significant proportion of Nigerian academics have published in predatory journals, driven by pressures to publish and a lack of awareness. The consequences of this practice include the dissemination of unreliable research, damage to academic reputation, and erosion of public trust. The study recommends urgent interventions to address this issue, including education and awareness campaigns, improved access to reputable journals, and stricter quality control measures.
Keywords
Full Text:
PDFReferences
Aboyade, Wahab Akanmu, Elizabeth O. Ndubuisi-Okoh, Chukwu Okoche, and Bolaji David Oladokun. 2024. "Impact of Predatory Journal Publishing on Scholarly Practices among Academic Librarians in Nigeria: A Systematic Review of Literature." Seminars in Medical Writing and Education 3:60-60.
Akça, Selcuk, and Mehmet Akbulut. 2021. "Are Predatory Journals Contaminating Science? An Analysis on the Cabells' Predatory Report." Journal of Academic Librarianship 47(4):102366.
Åkerlind, G. S. 2005. "Postdoctoral Researchers: Roles, Functions and Career Prospects." Higher Education Research & Development 24(1):21-40.
Alvesson, Mats, and Jörgen Sandberg. 2013. "Has Management Studies Lost Its Way? Ideas for More Imaginative and Innovative Research." Journal of Management Studies 50(1):128-52.
Amutuhaire, Timothy. 2022. "The Reality of the ‘Publish or Perish’ Concept, Perspectives from the Global South." Publishing Research Quarterly 38(2):281-94.
Bodolica, Virginia, and Mark Spraggon. 2018. "An End-to-End Process of Writing and Publishing Influential Literature Review Articles: Do’s and Don’ts." Management Decision 56(11):2472-86.
Boncori, Ilaria. 2020. "The Never-Ending Shift: A Feminist Reflection on Living and Organizing Academic Lives during the Coronavirus Pandemic." Gender, Work & Organization 27(5):677-82.
Bravo, Giangiacomo, et al. 2019. "The Effect of Publishing Peer Review Reports on Referee Behavior in Five Scholarly Journals." Nature Communications 10(1):1-8.
Carter, Jennifer, et al. 2018. "Academic ‘Place-Making’: Fostering Attachment, Belonging and Identity for Indigenous Students in Australian Universities." Teaching in Higher Education 23(2):243-60.
Cobey, Kelly D., et al. 2019. "Knowledge and Motivations of Researchers Publishing in Presumed Predatory Journals: A Survey." BMJ Open 9(3):e026516.
Colepicolo, Antonio. 2015. "Information Reliability for Academic Research: Review and Recommendations." New Library World 116(11/12):646-60.
Dekker, Henk D., and Joon A. Kim. 2022. "Mechanisms of Propagation and Factors Contributing to Beliefs in Neuromyths." In Learning Styles, Classroom Instruction, and Student Achievement, edited by H. D. Dekker and J. A. Kim, 21-37. Cham: Springer International Publishing.
Demir, Simber S. 2018. "Predatory Journals: Who Publishes in Them and Why?" Journal of Informetrics 12(4):1296-1311.
Downes, Michael. 2020. "Thousands of Australian Academics on the Editorial Boards of Journals Run by Predatory Publishers." Learned Publishing 33(3):287-95.
Dwivedi, Yogesh K., et al. 2022. "How to Develop a Quality Research Article and Avoid a Journal Desk Rejection." International Journal of Information Management 62:102426.
Ebadi, Samira, et al. 2020. "Exploring Arguments Presented in Predatory Journals Using Toulmin’s Model of Argumentation." Journal of Academic Ethics 18:435-49.
Edmondson, Amy C. 2018. "How Fearless Organizations Succeed." Strategy and Business.
Every-Palmer, Susanna, and Jenny Howick. 2014. "How Evidence-Based Medicine Is Failing Due to Biased Trials and Selective Publication." Journal of Evaluation in Clinical Practice 20(6):908-14.
Frynas, Jedrzej G., and Carlos Y. Yamahaki. 2016. "Corporate Social Responsibility: Review and Roadmap of Theoretical Perspectives." Business Ethics: A European Review 25(3):258-85.
Ghasemi, Ali, et al. 2023. "Scientific Publishing in Biomedicine: A Brief History of Scientific Journals." International Journal of Endocrinology and Metabolism 21(1).
Ghasemi, Amir, Parvin Mirmiran, Kourosh Kashfi, and Zatollah Bahadoran. 2023. "Scientific Publishing in Biomedicine: A Brief History of Scientific Journals." International Journal of Endocrinology and Metabolism 21(1).
Gill, Gitanjali. 2021. "The Predatory Journal: Victimizer or Victim?" Informing Science 24:51.
Gin, Lauren E., Amanda A. Rowland, Brittany Steinwand, Jennifer Bruno, and Lisa A. Corwin. 2018. "Students Who Fail to Achieve Predefined Research Goals May Still Experience Many Positive Outcomes as a Result of CURE Participation." CBE—Life Sciences Education 17(4):ar57.
Govaerts, Rafaël, Eimear Nic Lughadha, Neil Black, Ruth Turner, and Alan Paton. 2021. "The World Checklist of Vascular Plants, a Continuously Updated Resource for Exploring Global Plant Diversity." Scientific Data 8(1):215.
Grudniewicz, Agnes, David Moher, Kyle D. Cobey, Glenn L. Bryson, Susannah Cukier, Kate Allen, and Manoj M. Lalu. 2019. "Predatory Journals: No Definition, No Defence." Nature 576(7786):210-12.
Guerra-Pujol, F. E. 2017. "Legal Liability for Data Fraud." Statistical Journal of the IAOS 33(3):755-61.
Henry, M. A., Sarah Shorter, Lucas Charkoudian, Jennifer M. Heemstra, and Lisa A. Corwin. 2019. "FAIL Is Not a Four-Letter Word: A Theoretical Framework for Exploring Undergraduate Students’ Approaches to Academic Challenge and Responses to Failure in STEM Learning Environments." CBE—Life Sciences Education 18(1):ar11.
Huang, Y., S. K. Pang, and S. Yu. 2018. "Academic Identities and University Faculty Responses to New Managerialist Reforms: Experiences from China." Studies in Higher Education 43(1):154-72.
Horn, Susan A. 2016. "The Social and Psychological Costs of Peer Review: Stress and Coping with Manuscript Rejection." Journal of Management Inquiry 25(1):11-26.
Hodson, Derek. 2013. "Nature of Science in the Science Curriculum: Origin, Development, Implications and Shifting Emphases." In International Handbook of Research in History, Philosophy and Science Teaching, edited by M. R. Matthews, pp. 911-70. Dordrecht: Springer Netherlands.
Ioannidis, John P., Sander Greenland, Mark A. Hlatky, Muin J. Khoury, Malcolm R. Macleod, David Moher, and Robert Tibshirani. 2014. "Increasing Value and Reducing Waste in Research Design, Conduct, and Analysis." The Lancet 383(9912):166-75.
Jackson, Leon, Michael A. Peters, Lorraine Benade, Nesta Devine, Stefan Arndt, Don Forster, and Jekaterina Ozoliņš. 2018. "Is Peer Review in Academic Publishing Still Working?" Open Review of Educational Research 5(1):95-112.
Jackson, Debra, Caroline Haigh, and Roger Watson. 2009. "Nurses and Publications—The Impact of the Impact Factor." Journal of Clinical Nursing 18(18):2537.
Kaldas, Michael, Sama Michael, Jason Hanna, and George M. Yousef. 2020. "Journal Impact Factor: A Bumpy Ride in an Open Space." Journal of Investigative Medicine 68(1):83-87.
Kallio, Katja M., Tomi J. Kallio, Janne Tienari, and Tuomas Hyvönen. 2016. "Ethos at Stake: Performance Management and Academic Work in Universities." Human Relations 69(3):685-709.
Klettner, Andrea, Thomas Clarke, and Martijn Boersma. 2016. "Strategic and Regulatory Approaches to Increasing Women in Leadership: Multilevel Targets and Mandatory Quotas as Levers for Cultural Change." Journal of Business Ethics 133:395-419.
Koerber, Amy, Jennifer C. Starkey, Karin Ardon-Dryer, Rachel G. Cummins, Lynda Eko, and Kenneth F. Kee. 2020. "A Qualitative Content Analysis of Watchlists vs Safelists: How Do They Address the Issue of Predatory Publishing?" The Journal of Academic Librarianship 46(6):102236.
Kumar, Satish, Nishant Pandey, Weng Marc Lim, Abhishek N. Chatterjee, and Nisha Pandey. 2021. "What Do We Know About Transfer Pricing? Insights from Bibliometric Analysis." Journal of Business Research 134:275-87.
Kurt, Serap. 2018. "Why Do Authors Publish in Predatory Journals?" Learned Publishing 31(2):141-47.
Lathabai, H. H., T. Prabhakaran, and M. Changat. 2015. "Centrality and Flow Vergence Gradient Based Path Analysis of Scientific Literature: A Case Study of Biotechnology for Engineering." Physica A: Statistical Mechanics and Its Applications 429:157-68.
Leeson, Robert and Peter Leeson. 2019. "Summoned to Service by TOFF Funds and Aristocratic Bells." Pp. 199-268 in Hayek: A Collaborative Biography, Part VIII: The Constitution of Liberty: 'Shooting in Cold Blood', Hayek's Plan for the Future of Democracy.
Lillis, Theresa and Mary Jane Curry. 2018. "Trajectories of Knowledge and Desire: Multilingual Women Scholars Researching and Writing in Academia." Journal of English for Academic Purposes 32:53-66.
Manley, Stephen. 2019. "Predatory Journals on Trial: Allegations, Responses, and Lessons for Scholarly Publishing from FTC v. OMICS." Journal of Scholarly Publishing 50(3):183-200.
Mathew, Ravi P. and Vivek Patel. 2022. "Predatory Journals—The Power of the Predator versus the Integrity of the Honest." Current Problems in Diagnostic Radiology 51(5):740-46.
Matumba, Lucas, Frank Maulidi, Mulatu Balehegn, Fisseha Abay, Gift Salanje, Leonard Dzimbiri, and Emmanuel Kaunda. 2019. "Blacklisting or Whitelisting? Deterring Faculty in Developing Countries from Publishing in Substandard Journals." Journal of Scholarly Publishing 50(2):83-95.
Mesgari, Mostafa, Chitu Okoli, Mehdi Mehdi, Finn Årup Nielsen, and Arto Lanamäki. 2015. "'The Sum of All Human Knowledge': A Systematic Review of Scholarly Research on the Content of Wikipedia." Journal of the Association for Information Science and Technology 66(2):219-45.
McCann, Terence V. and Michael Polacsek. 2018. "False Gold: Safely Navigating Open Access Publishing to Avoid Predatory Publishers and Journals." Journal of Advanced Nursing 74(4):809-17.
McKenzie, Lisa. 2021. "Unequal Expressions: Emotions and Narratives of Leaving and Remaining in Precarious Academia." Social Anthropology/Anthropologie Sociale 29(2):527-42.
McKelvey, Maureen and Björn Rake. 2020. "Exploring Scientific Publications by Firms: What Are the Roles of Academic and Corporate Partners for Publications in High Reputation or High Impact Journals?" Scientometrics 122(3):1323-60.
Miller, John J. 2017. "Publish or Perish?" Pp. 85-100 in Critical Essays in Sport Management, edited by D. L. Andrews. Routledge.
Mills, David and Kristina Inouye. 2021. "Problematizing ‘Predatory Publishing’: A Systematic Review of Factors Shaping Publishing Motives, Decisions, and Experiences." Learned Publishing 34(2):89-104.
Mills, David, and Abigail Branford. 2022. "Getting by in a Bibliometric Economy: Scholarly Publishing and Academic Credibility in the Nigerian Academy." Africa 92(5):839-859.
Mills, David, Amy Branford, Kristina Inouye, Nick Robinson, and Peter Kingori. 2021. "‘Fake’ Journals and the Fragility of Authenticity: Citation Indexes, ‘Predatory’ Publishing, and the African Research Ecosystem." Journal of African Cultural Studies 33(3):276-96
Minasny, Budiman, Dina Fiantis, Budi Mulyanto, Yudha Sulaeman, and Widi Widyatmanti. 2020. "Global Soil Science Research Collaboration in the 21st Century: Time to End Helicopter Research." Geoderma 373:114299.
Moher, David, Paul Glasziou, Iain Chalmers, Moin Nasser, Patrick M. Bossuyt, Daan A. Korevaar, and Isabelle Boutron. 2016. "Increasing Value and Reducing Waste in Biomedical Research: Who's Listening?" The Lancet 387(10027):1573-86.
Mousavi, Tayebeh and Mohammad Abdollahi. 2020. "A Review of the Current Concerns about Misconduct in Medical Sciences Publications and the Consequences." DARU Journal of Pharmaceutical Sciences 28:359-69.
Morgan, James and Darja Sisak. 2016. "Aspiring to Succeed: A Model of Entrepreneurship and Fear of Failure." Journal of Business Venturing 31(1):1-21.
Moses, James M. and William Shem. 2022. "Predatory Publications among Academics in Nigerian Universities: A Narrative Review." World Scientific News 173:149-61.
Nederhof, Anton J. 2006. "Bibliometric Monitoring of Research Performance in the Social Sciences and the Humanities: A Review." Scientometrics 66(1):81-100.
Nejadghanbar, Hassan, Guangwei Hu, and Mohammad Javad Babadi. 2023. "Publishing in Predatory Language and Linguistics Journals: Authors’ Experiences and Motivations." Language Teaching, online first, 1-16.
Nicholas, David, Anthony Watkinson, Chaaban Boukacem-Zeghmouri, Blanca Rodríguez-Bravo, Jian Xu, Abrizah Abdullah, and Eti Herman. 2017. "Early Career Researchers: Scholarly Behaviour and the Prospect of Change." Learned Publishing 30(2):157-66.
Nwankwo, Theodore Victor, Richard Amareshi Odiachi, and Ifeanyi Anajudo Anene. 2022. "Black Articles Matter: Exploring Relative Deprivation and Implicit Bias in Library and Information Science Research Publications of Africa and Other Continents." Library Hi Tech 40(3):651-75.
Omobowale, Ayo O., Oluwafemi Akanle, Adeniyi Isiaka Adeniran, and Kehinde Adegboyega. 2014. "Peripheral Scholarship and the Context of Foreign Paid Publishing in Nigeria." Current Sociology 62(5):666-84.
Opie, Taiwo. 2018. "Hitting Academic Research Target." Paper presented at the 1st National Workshop on Pragmatics Research, Department of English, Lagos State University (LASU).
Packalen, Mikko and Jay Bhattacharya. 2017. "Neophilia Ranking of Scientific Journals." Scientometrics 110:43-64.
Perry, Elizabeth J. 2020. "Educated Acquiescence: How Academia Sustains Authoritarianism in China." Theory and Society 49(1):1-22.
Pisoschi, Aurel M. and Catalin G. Pisoschi. 2016. "Is Open Access the Solution to Increase the Impact of Scientific Journals?" Scientometrics 109(2):1075-95.
Reiter, Renate and Thomas Klenk. 2019. "The Manifold Meanings of ‘Post-New Public Management’–A Systematic Literature Review." International Review of Administrative Sciences 85(1):11-27.
Richtig, Georg, Martin Berger, Birgitta Lange-Aschenfeldt, Wolfgang Aberer, and Eva Richtig. 2018. "Problems and Challenges of Predatory Journals." Journal of the European Academy of Dermatology and Venereology 32(9):1441-49.
Roldan-Valadez, Eduardo, Sergio Y. Salazar-Ruiz, Roberto Ibarra-Contreras, and Cristina Rios. 2019. "Current Concepts on Bibliometrics: A Brief Review about Impact Factor, Eigenfactor Score, CiteScore, SCImago Journal Rank, Source-Normalised Impact per Paper, H-Index, and Alternative Metrics." Irish Journal of Medical Science 188:939-51.
Rupp, Maximilian, Lida Anastasopoulou, Eva Wintermeyer, Daniel Malhaan, Omar El Khassawna, and Christian Heiss. 2019. "Predatory Journals: A Major Threat in Orthopaedic Research." International Orthopaedics 43:509-17.
Shaghaei, Navid, Christian Wien, Jacob P. Holck, Anna L. Thiesen, Ole Ellegaard, Evangelos Vlachos, and Tim M. Drachen. 2018. "Being a Deliberate Prey of a Predator: Researchers’ Thoughts after Having Published in a Predatory Journal." LIBER Quarterly: The Journal of the Association of European Research Libraries 28(1):1-17.
Shamseer, Larissa, David Moher, Osondu O. Maduekwe, Laura Turner, Virginia Barbour, Rebecca Burch, et al. 2017. "Potential Predatory and Legitimate Biomedical Journals: Can You Tell the Difference? A Cross-Sectional Comparison." BMC Medicine 15(1):1-14.
Sharma, Abhishek, Manoj S. Dash, Vrushali Pawar, and Mayur A. Vhatkar. 2023. "The Indian Struggle Against Predatory Journals: The Importance of Quality Control." Journal of Pharmaceutical Negative Results:556-60.
Shehata, Ahmed M. K. and Mohamed F. M. Elgllab. 2018. "Where Arab Social Science and Humanities Scholars Choose to Publish: Falling in the Predatory Journals Trap." Learned Publishing 31(3):222-29.
Shepherd, Dean A., Holger Patzelt, Timothy A. Williams, and Davide Warnecke. 2014. "How Does Project Termination Impact Project Team Members? Rapid Termination, ‘Creeping Death,’ and Learning from Failure." Journal of Management Studies 51(4):513-46.
Sorokowski, Piotr, Ewa Kulczycki, Agnieszka Sorokowska, and Katarzyna Pisanski. 2017. "Predatory Journals Recruit Fake Editor." Nature 543(7646):481-83.
Stephens Balakrishnan, Melodena. 2013. "Methods to Increase Research Output: Some Tips Looking at the MENA Region." International Journal of Emerging Markets 8(3):215-39.
Tella, Adeyinka. 2020. "Nigerian Academics Patronizing Predatory Journals: Implications for Scholarly Communication." Journal of Scholarly Publishing 51(3):182-96.
Tennant, Jonathan P., Heather Crane, Tim Crick, Jonathan Davila, Enkhbayar, Jo Havemann, and Michael Vanholsbeeck. 2019. "Ten Hot Topics around Scholarly Publishing." Publications 7(2):34.
Teixeira da Silva, Jaime A., Ahmad Al-Khatib, Vladimir Katavić, and Helmut Bornemann-Cimenti. 2018. "Establishing Sensible and Practical Guidelines for Desk Rejections." Science and Engineering Ethics 24:1347-65.
Vessuri, Hebe, Jean-Claude Guédon, and Ana María Cetto. 2014. "Excellence or Quality? Impact of the Current Competition Regime on Science and Scientific Publishing in Latin America and Its Implications for Development." Current Sociology 62(5):647-65.
Vuong, Quan-Hoang. 2019. "The Harsh World of Publishing in Emerging Regions and Implications for Editors and Publishers: The Case of Vietnam." Learned Publishing 32(4):314-24.
Wallace, Frederick H. and Timothy J. Perri. 2018. "Economists Behaving Badly: Publications in Predatory Journals." Scientometrics 115:749-66.
Wang, Kai, Zhi Shen, Chuan Huang, Chih-Hsien Wu, David Eide, Yi Dong, et al. 2019. "A Review of Microsoft Academic Services for Science of Science Studies." Frontiers in Big Data 2:45.
Wald, Hedy S., Aviad Haramati, Yoram G. Bachner, and Jacob Urkin. 2016. "Promoting Resiliency for Interprofessional Faculty and Senior Medical Students: Outcomes of a Workshop Using Mind-Body Medicine and Interactive Reflective Writing." Medical Teacher 38(5):525-28.
Walters, William H. 2022. "The Citation Impact of the Open Access Accounting Journals That Appear on Beall's List of Potentially Predatory Publishers and Journals." Journal of Academic Librarianship 48(1):102484.
Xu, Jian, Jia Ying Wang, Li Zhou, and Fei Liu. 2019. "Internationalization of China's English-Language Academic Journals: An Overview and Three Approaches." Learned Publishing 32(2):113-25.
Yeo, Michelle Ai Ling, Willy A. Renandya, and Sukanya Tangkiengsirisin. 2022. "Re-envisioning Academic Publication: From ‘Publish or Perish’ to ‘Publish and Flourish’." RELC Journal 53(1):266-75.
Article Metrics
Refbacks
- There are currently no refbacks.
Copyright (c) 2025 Jurnal Pemikiran Sosiologi

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 4.0 International License.
Jurnal Pemikiran Sosiologi Indexed by:
ISSN 2252-570X (Print), ISSN 2502-2059 (online).











