Keywords
Pandemic
COVID-19
Adaptive Governance
Social Policy
COVID-19
Adaptive Governance
Social Policy
How to Cite
Pamungkas, S. H. A., Daffaakbar, M. A., & Nurrizky, A. M. (2022). Analisis Tata Kelola Kebijakan Sosial Penanganan Pandemi COVID-19 di Indonesia Berdasarkan Perspektif Adaptive Governance. Journal of Social Development Studies, 3(2). https://doi.org/10.22146/jsds.5226
Abstract
Abstrak
Pandemi COVID-19 merupakan tantangan besar yang dihadapi seluruh negara di dunia sejak tahun 2020. Kebijakan sosial menjadi instrumen kebijakan paling penting pada masa pandemi. Pandemi COVID-19 memiliki karakteristik dinamis, eksponensial, serta dipenuhi kompleksitas dan ketidakpastian. Hal ini membuat implementasi kebijakan sosial perlu dilakukan dengan dasar tata kelola adaptif (adaptive governance). Studi ini melakukan analisis komparatif terhadap implementasi kebijakan sosial di Indonesia dan Brazil pada periode pandemi. Analisis dilakukan berdasarkan 7 indikator tata kelola adaptif yang dioperasikan dalam flexible arrangements dan barriers to flexible arrangements. Temuan dari studi ini menunjukkan bahwa di Indonesia, proses kebijakan, konten kebijakan, dan struktur organisasi bersifat fleksibel. Namun, terdapat konflik kepentingan, ketidakjelasan distribusi kewenangan, ketidakjelasan distribusi biaya & manfaat, dan distrust. Sementara di Brazil, konten kebijakan fleksibel namun proses kebijakan dan struktur organisasi tidak fleksibel. Selain itu, terdapat konflik kepentingan dan distrust, namun tidak terdapat ketidakjelasan distribusi kewenangan maupun distribusi biaya & manfaat.
Kata Kunci: Pandemi, COVID-19, Adaptive Governance, Kebijakan Sosial.
Abstract
The COVID-19 pandemic is a major challenge faced by countries worldwide since 2020. Social policy, therefore, becomes an important policy instrument. Characteristically, the pandemic is dynamic, exponential, and filled with complexity and uncertainty. This makes adaptive governance crucial to the implementation of social policies. This study compares the implementation of social policies in Indonesia and Brazil during the pandemic. The analysis is based on 7 indicators of adaptive governance, operationalized in flexible arrangements and barriers to flexible arrangements. The findings shows that in Indonesia, the policy process, policy content, and organizational structure are flexible. However, there are conflicts of interest, unclear distribution of authority, unclear distribution of costs & benefits, and distrust. In Brazil, the policy content is flexible, while the policy process and organizational structure are not. Conflict of interest and distrust are present, while the distribution of authority and distribution of costs & benefits are clear.
Keywords: Pandemic, COVID-19, Adaptive Governance, Social Policy.
References
ACLED. (2020). Pandemic and Political Unrest in Brazil and Nicaragua. Armed Conflict Location & Event Data Project (ACLED).
Adikara, B. (2021). Penyaluran Bansos Lambat, Jokowi Akui Akurasi Data Pemerintah Rendah. Jawa Pos.
https://www.jawapos.com/nasional/27/05/2021/penyaluran-bansos-lambat-jokowi-akui-akurasi-data-pemerintah-rendah/
Akib, I. & Risfaisal, R. (2016). Bantuan Langsung Tunai. Jurnal Equilibrium Pendidikan Sosiologi Vol. III No. 2 November 2016. ISSN e-2477-0221 p-2339-2401 https://media.neliti.com/media/publications/60945-ID-bantuan-langsung-tunai.pdf
Ali, Shehzad., Asaria, Miqdad., Stranges Saverio. (2020). Covid-19 and Inequality: are we all in this together?. Kanada: Canadian Journal of Public Health.Arnold,
Alves, G. (2020). Após declarar FIM do Renda Cidadã, quais planos do governo para NOVO programa social? FDR. https://fdr.com.br/2020/12/09/apos-declarar-fim-do-renda-cidada-quais-planos-do-governo-para-novo-programa-social/ diakses pada 26 Juli 2022
Anwar, M. C. (2021). 17,4 Juta Orang Dapat Bansos, Cek Data Penerima di dtks.kemensos.go.id. Kompas. https://money.kompas.com/read/2021/03/31/131133426/174-juta-orang-dapat-bansos-cek-data-penerima-di-dtkskemensosgoid?page=all diakses pada 19 Juli 2022
Associated Press News. (2021). US budget deficit hits $2.77 trillion in 2021, 2nd highest. https://apnews.com/article/business-economy-government-spending-financial-crisis-14dab966ccfab3e22c5f4095f84542fa diakses pada 23 Maret 2022
Barany, L.J., Simanjuntak, I., Widia, D. A., & Damuri, R. Y. (2020). Bantuan Sosial Ekonomi di Tengah Pandemi COVID-19: Sudahkah Menjaring Sesuai Sasaran? CSIS Commentaries ECON-002-ID: 15 April 2020.
Batubara, P. J. (2020). Bantuan “Social Safety Net” Kementerian Sosial bagi Keluarga Miskin dan Rentan terdampak Covid-19. Kementerian Sosial. https://www.kemsos.go.id/ diakses pada 13 Juli 2022
Bayu, D. J. (2020). Jokowi Bentuk Gugus Tugas Percepatan Penanganan Covid-19. Katadata. https://katadata.co.id/agustiyanti/berita/5e9a4214bc69e/jokowi-bentuk-gugus-tugas-percepatan-penanganan-covid-19
Bayu, D. J. (2020). Ombudsman Terima 1.346 Laporan Soal Bansos selama Pandemi Corona. Katadata. https://katadata.co.id/ekarina/berita/5f2a8494bf9b9/ombudsman-terima-1346-laporan-soal-bansos-selama-pandemi-corona
BBC News. (2021). Bansos PPKM darurat dan level 4: Data penerima 'bermasalah', cerita warga: 'Jangankan dapat bantuan, didata saja tidak pernah'. BBC News https://www.bbc.com/indonesia/indonesia-57746385 diakses pada 21 Juli 2022
BBC News. (2021). Covid-19: Brazil to get fourth health minister since pandemic began. BBC News. https://www.bbc.com/news/world-latin-america-56410626 diakses pada 7 Juli 2022.
Bennouna et. al., C. (2021). Pandemic Policymaking in Presidential Federations: Explaining Subnational Responses to Covid-19 in Brazil, Mexico, and the United States. The Journal of Federalism, 51(4), 570-600.
Biller, D., & Savarese, M. (2020). Brazil cities lurch to lockdowns amid virus crisis red flags. Associated Press. https://apnews.com/article/public-health-health-rio-de-janeiro-ap-top-news-brazil-51e0ad7ee7d1ce702bdf887df466d047 diakses pada 10 Juli 2022.
Blofield, M., & Filgueira, F. (2020). COVID19 and Latin America: Social Impact, Policies and a Fiscal Case for an Emergency Social Protection Floor. Buenos Aires: CIPPEC.
Blofield, M., Hoffmann, B., & Llanos, M. (2020). Assessing the Political and Social Impact of the COVID-19 Crisis in Latin America. German Institute of Global and Area Studies (GIGA) Focus(3), 1-12.
Blofield, Merike., dan Hoffmann, Bert. (2020). Social Policy Responses to the COVID-19 Crisis and the Road Ahead. German Institute of Global and Area Studies. https://www.jstor.org/stable/resrep27045 diakses pada 30 Juni 2022 melalui
Boadle, A. (2021). Brazil Senate OKs easing budget cap to fund welfare program. Reuters. https://www.reuters.com/world/americas/brazil-senate-oks-easing-budget-cap-fund-welfare-program-2021-12-02/ diakses pada 23 Juli 2022.
Brito, R., & Ayres, M. (2020). Brazil's government backs new basic income payments to poor. Reuters. https://www.reuters.com/article/us-brazil-economics-idUSKBN26J381 diakses pada 24 Juli 2022
Cahyadi, I. R. (2020). Relawan Pendukung Gugus Tugas Bagikan Bansos untuk Warga Jabodetabek. Beritasatu https://www.beritasatu.com/kesehatan/639449/relawan-pendukung-gugus-tugas-bagikan-bansos-untuk-warga-jabodetabek diakses pada 18 Juli 2022
Carayannis, E. G., Samara, E. T., & Bakouros, Y. L. (2015). Innovation and entrepreneurship: theory, policy and practice. Springer.
Chaffin, B. C., H. Gosnell, and B. A. Cosens. (2014). A decade of adaptive governance scholarship: synthesis and future directions. Ecology and Society 19(3): 56
Cleaver, F., and L. Whaley. (2018). Understanding process, power, and meaning in adaptive governance: a critical institutional reading. Ecology and Society 23(2):49
CNN Indonesia. (2020). Kekacauan Bansos Corona, Masalah Klasik Big Data. https://www.cnnindonesia.com/nasional/20200508133813-20-501305/kekacauan-bansos-corona-masalah-klasik-big-data diakses pada 21 Juli 2022
CNN Indonesia. (2021). Pemda Dinilai 'Lelet' Salurkan Bansos. https://www.cnnindonesia.com/ekonomi/20210316142405-532-618103/pemda-dinilai-lelet-salurkan-bansos diakses pada 21 Juli 2022
Creswell, John., dan Poth, Cheril. (2018). Qualitative inquiry and research design: choosing among five approaches. London: SAGE
de Melo, M. C., Silva, A. G., Melo, R. A., & de Freitas, C. A. (2020). COVID-19 pandemic outbreak: the Brazilian reality from the first case to the collapse of health services. Anais da Academia Brasileira de Ciências | Annals of the Brazilian Academy of Sciences, 92(4), 1-14.
Dewi, S. R. (2020). Evaluasi Penyaluran Bantuan Sosial (Bansos) Tahap Satu, Covid-19. Ombudsman Republik Indonesia. https://ombudsman.go.id/artikel/r/artikel--evaluasi-penyaluran-bantuan-sosial-bansos-tahap-satu-covid-19- diakses pada 15 Juli 2022
Dang. (2022). COVID-19 in Viet Nam. New York: Routledge
DW. (2022). COVID pandemic pushes Germany to largest deficit since reunification. https://www.dw.com/en/covid-pandemic-pushes-germany-to-largest-deficit-since-reunification/a-57118164 diakses pada 23 Maret 2022
Firey, Thomas. (2020). Government in a Pandemic. Cato Institute, Policy Analysis No. 902. https://www.jstor.org/stable/resrep26889 diakses pada 30 Juni 2022
Fernandes, A., & Vargas, M. (2019, July 12). Governo vai reformular Bolsa Família e destinar benefício a jovens e crianças. UOL. https://economia.uol.com.br/noticias/estadao-conteudo/2019/12/07/governo-vai-reformular-bolsa-familia-e-destinar-beneficio-a-jovens-e-criancas.htm diakses pada 21 Juli 2022.
G1. (2020). 2,5 milhões receberam auxílio emergencial de R$ 600 nesta quinta. G1. https://g1.globo.com/economia/noticia/2020/04/09/6-milhoes-comecam-a-receber-auxilio-emergencial-de-r-600-nesta-quinta.ghtml diakses pada 9 Juli 2022
G1. (2021, December 25). Datafolha: brasileiro está dividido sobre substituição do Bolsa Família por Auxílio Brasil. G1. https://g1.globo.com/politica/noticia/2021/12/25/datafolha-brasileiro-esta-dividido-sobre-substituicao-do-bolsa-familia-por-auxilio-brasil.ghtml diakses pada 26 Juli 2022.
Gazola Hellman, A. (2015). How does Bolsa Família Work? Best Practices in the Implementation of Conditional Cash Transfer Programs in Latin America and the Caribbean. Inter-American Development Bank.
Gibson, John., Olivia, Susan. 2020. Direct and Indirect Effects of Covid-19 On Life Expectancy and Poverty in Indonesia. Jakarta: Bulletin of Indonesian Economic Studies.
Gosnell, H., Chaffin, B. C., Ruhl, J. B., Arnold, C. A., Craig, R. K., Benson, M. H., & Devenish, A. (2017). Transforming (perceived) rigidity in environmental law through adaptive governance. Ecology and Society, Vol. 22, No. 4.
Greer, Scott., King, Elizabeth., dan Fonseca, Elize. (2021). Coronavirus Politics: The Comparative Politics and Policy of COVID-19. Michigan: University of Michigan Press.
Greer et. al., S. (2021). Social policy as an integral component of pandemic response: Learning from COVID-19 in Brazil, Germany, India and the United States. Global Public Health, 16(8-9), 1209-1222.
Hermawati, I. & Risambessy, J. (2021). Asesmen Bantuan Sosial pada Masa Pandemi Covid-19 bagi Keluarga Miskin dan Rentan di Daerah Istimewa Yogyakarta. Jurnal PKS Vol 20 No 3 Desember 2021; 293 - 308
Hidayat, A.A. N. (2020). Penyaluran Bansos Lambat, Jokowi Minta 3 Menteri Ini Kerja Cepat. Tempo. https://bisnis.tempo.co/read/1343117/penyaluran-bansos-lambat-jokowi-minta-3-menteri-ini-kerja-cepat diakses pada 27 Juli 2022
Jarman, Holly. (2021). State Responses to the COVID-19 Pandemic: Governance, Surveillance, Coercion, and Social Policy. Michigan: University of Michigan Press.
Jeantet, D. (2021, November 18). Brazil swaps acclaimed welfare program for untested stand-in. Associated Press. https://apnews.com/article/business-brazil-jair-bolsonaro-rio-de-janeiro-85e900a6d9f66caacac082cb1b36b242 diakses pada 12 Juli 2022
KPMG. (2020, September 9). Brazil: Government and institution measures in response to COVID-19. KPMG. https://home.kpmg/xx/en/home/insights/2020/04/brazil-government-and-institution-measures-in-response-to-covid.html diakses pada 13 Juli 2022.
Laan, T., Roth, J., & Beedell, E. (2021). Nordic environmental fiscal reform. International Institute for Sustainable Development. https://www.iisd.org/publications/nordicenvironmental-fiscal-reform-post-pandemic-recovery diakses pada 27 Juli 2022
Lindert, K., Linder, A., Hobbs, J., & de la Brière, B. (2007, May). The Nuts and Bolts of Brazil’s Bolsa Família Program: Implementing Conditional Cash Transfers in a Decentralized Context. Social Protection Discussion Paper (709).
Marcello, M. C. (2021, November 26). Brazil's lower house approves replacement of Brazil's famed Bolsa Família. Reuters. https://www.reuters.com/world/americas/brazils-lower-house-approves-replacement-brazils-famed-bolsa-familia-2021-11-25/ diakses pada 25 Juli 2022
McCoy, T. L. (2016, October 4). As Brazil tilts rightward, Lula’s leftist legacy of lifting the poor is at risk. The Conversation. https://theconversation.com/as-brazil-tilts-rightward-lulas-leftist-legacy-of-lifting-the-poor-is-at-risk-65939 diakses pada 26 July 2022.
Mendez, Claudio. (2021). The Politics of the COVID-19 Pandemic Response In Chile. Michigan: University of Michigan Press.
Mufida, A. (2020). Polemik Pemberian Bantuan Sosial Di Tengah Pandemic Covid-19. ADALAH: Buletin Hukum & Keadilan, 4(1), p.159–166
Murphy, Mary. (2021). A New Welfare Imaginary for the Island of Ireland. Irish Studies in International Affairs, Vol. 32, No. 2.
Negara. (2022). COVID-19 Impacts and Recovery: Lessons Learned from Singapore. New York: Routledge.
Noerkaisar, Noni. (2021). Efektivitas Penyaluran Bantuan Sosial Pemerintah Untuk Mengatasi Dampak Covid-19 di Indonesia. JEL Classification, N4, N9, 83-104.
Novrizaldi. (2020). Tahap 2 Penyaluran JPS, Pemerintah Tambahkan Program Bantuan Beras dan Bantuan Uang Tunai. Kemenko PMK. https://www.kemenkopmk.go.id/tahap-2-penyaluran-jps-pemerintah-tambahkan-program-bantuan-beras-dan-bantuan-uang-tunai diakses pada 25 Juli 2022
Nugent, C. (2022). Lula Talks to TIME About Ukraine, Bolsonaro, and Brazil's Fragile Democracy. TIME. https://time.com/6173232/lula-da-silva-transcript/ diakses pada 27 Juli 2022.
O Sul. (2019). O presidente Bolsonaro criou o 13º salário do Bolsa Família. O Sul. https://www.osul.com.br/o-presidente-bolsonaro-criou-o-13o-salario-do-bolsa-familia/ diakses pada 25 Juli, 2022.
Olivia, Susan., Gibson, John., Nasrudin Rus’an. 2020. Indonesia in the Time of Covid-19. Jakarta: Bulletin of Indonesian Economic Studies.
Ozcurumez, Saime. (2021). COVID-19 In Turkey: Public Health Centralism. Michigan: University of Michigan Press.
Paraguassu, L. (2020, May 6). Major Brazilian cities set lockdowns as virus spreads. Reuters. https://www.reuters.com/article/us-health-coronavirus-brazil-lockdown-idUSKBN22H2V3 diakses pada 10 Juli 2022.
Romer, Christina., dan Rome, David. (2022). A Social Insurance Perspective on Pandemic Fiscal Policy. The Journal of Economic Perspectives, Vol. 36, No.2.
RSSEE SG. (2020). The Western Balkan Countries in the Face of the COVID-19 Pandemic. Connections QJ, Vol. 19, No. 2.
Resende, T. (2019, October 1). Bolsa Família volta a ter fila de espera e corre risco de encolher. Folha de S.Paulo. https://www1.folha.uol.com.br/mercado/2019/10/bolsa-familia-volta-a-ter-fila-de-espera-e-corre-risco-de-encolher.shtml diakses pada 24 July 2022.
Schulze. (2022). Policy Responses to the COVID-19 Pandemic: The Case of Germany. New York: Routledge.
Setiawan, R. (2021). Sengkarut Data Bansos COVID yang Berimbas Penundaan hingga Pungli. Tirto. https://tirto.id/gilN diakses pada 23 Juli 2022
Sugiarto, E.C. (2020). Menjaga Momentum Pemulihan Ekonomi. Setkab. https://setkab.go.id/menjaga-momentum-pemulihan-ekonomi/ diakses pada 24 Juli 2022
Suryahadi, Asep., Al Izzati, Ridho., Suryadarma, Daniel. 2020. Estimating the Impact of Covid-19 on Poverty in Indonesia. Jakarta: Bulletin of Indonesian Economic Studies.
Temoteo, A., & Araújo, C. (2020, October 23). Governo Bolsonaro não deve pagar 13º salário do Bolsa Família em 2020. UOL. https://economia.uol.com.br/noticias/redacao/2020/10/23/bolsa-familia-governo-bolsonaro-pagamento.htm dipetik pada 24 Juli 2022.
The Economist. (2020). Bolsa Família, Brazil’s admired anti-poverty programme, is flailing. The Economist. https://www.economist.com/the-americas/2020/01/30/bolsa-familia-brazils-admired-anti-poverty-programme-is-flailing diakses pada 24 Juli 2022
The World Bank Group. (2020). World Bank approves loan supporting the expansion of the Bolsa Família Program. The World Bank. https://www.worldbank.org/en/news/press-release/2020/10/29/world-bank-approves-loan-supporting-expansion-of-bolsa-familia-program diakses pada 26 Juli 2022
UNCTAD. (2022). China’s structural transformation: what can developing countries learn? UNCTAD.https://unctad.org/webflyer/chinas-structural-transformation-what-can-developing-countries-learn diakses pada 10 Mei 2022
UNCTAD. (2020). South-South Cooperation at the time of COVID-19: Building Solidarity Among Developing Countries. UNCTAD. https://unctad.org/system/files/official-document/gdsinf2020d4_en.pdf diakses pada 27 Juli 2022
WHO. (2020). Preventing and Managing COVID-19 Across Long-term Care Services. WHO. https://www.jstor.org/stable/resrep27994.6 diakses pada 30 Juni 2022
Van Buuren, A., A. M. Keessen, C. Van Leeuwen, J. Eshuis, and G. J. Ellen. (2015). Implementation arrangements for climate adaptation in the Netherlands: characteristics and underlying mechanisms of adaptive governance. Ecology and Society 20(4):11
Victoria, A. O. (2020). Sri Mulyani Keluhkan Data Masih Hambat Penyaluran Bansos Rp 81 Triliun. Katadata. https://katadata.co.id/agustiyanti/finansial/5fac5200590a1/sri-mulyani-keluhkan-data-masih-hambat-penyaluran-bansos-rp-81-triliun diakses pada 25 Juli 2022
Yunita, I. & Agustang, A. (2021). Ketidakmerataan Bantuan Langsung Tunai Di Masa Pandemi Covid-19 Pada Masyarakat Kurang Mampu di Desa Carawali Kabupaten Sidrap. Pinisi Journal Of Sociology Education Review; Vol. 1; No. 2; Juli 2021, p.181-191. http://103.76.50.195/jser/article/view/22208
Adikara, B. (2021). Penyaluran Bansos Lambat, Jokowi Akui Akurasi Data Pemerintah Rendah. Jawa Pos.
https://www.jawapos.com/nasional/27/05/2021/penyaluran-bansos-lambat-jokowi-akui-akurasi-data-pemerintah-rendah/
Akib, I. & Risfaisal, R. (2016). Bantuan Langsung Tunai. Jurnal Equilibrium Pendidikan Sosiologi Vol. III No. 2 November 2016. ISSN e-2477-0221 p-2339-2401 https://media.neliti.com/media/publications/60945-ID-bantuan-langsung-tunai.pdf
Ali, Shehzad., Asaria, Miqdad., Stranges Saverio. (2020). Covid-19 and Inequality: are we all in this together?. Kanada: Canadian Journal of Public Health.Arnold,
Alves, G. (2020). Após declarar FIM do Renda Cidadã, quais planos do governo para NOVO programa social? FDR. https://fdr.com.br/2020/12/09/apos-declarar-fim-do-renda-cidada-quais-planos-do-governo-para-novo-programa-social/ diakses pada 26 Juli 2022
Anwar, M. C. (2021). 17,4 Juta Orang Dapat Bansos, Cek Data Penerima di dtks.kemensos.go.id. Kompas. https://money.kompas.com/read/2021/03/31/131133426/174-juta-orang-dapat-bansos-cek-data-penerima-di-dtkskemensosgoid?page=all diakses pada 19 Juli 2022
Associated Press News. (2021). US budget deficit hits $2.77 trillion in 2021, 2nd highest. https://apnews.com/article/business-economy-government-spending-financial-crisis-14dab966ccfab3e22c5f4095f84542fa diakses pada 23 Maret 2022
Barany, L.J., Simanjuntak, I., Widia, D. A., & Damuri, R. Y. (2020). Bantuan Sosial Ekonomi di Tengah Pandemi COVID-19: Sudahkah Menjaring Sesuai Sasaran? CSIS Commentaries ECON-002-ID: 15 April 2020.
Batubara, P. J. (2020). Bantuan “Social Safety Net” Kementerian Sosial bagi Keluarga Miskin dan Rentan terdampak Covid-19. Kementerian Sosial. https://www.kemsos.go.id/ diakses pada 13 Juli 2022
Bayu, D. J. (2020). Jokowi Bentuk Gugus Tugas Percepatan Penanganan Covid-19. Katadata. https://katadata.co.id/agustiyanti/berita/5e9a4214bc69e/jokowi-bentuk-gugus-tugas-percepatan-penanganan-covid-19
Bayu, D. J. (2020). Ombudsman Terima 1.346 Laporan Soal Bansos selama Pandemi Corona. Katadata. https://katadata.co.id/ekarina/berita/5f2a8494bf9b9/ombudsman-terima-1346-laporan-soal-bansos-selama-pandemi-corona
BBC News. (2021). Bansos PPKM darurat dan level 4: Data penerima 'bermasalah', cerita warga: 'Jangankan dapat bantuan, didata saja tidak pernah'. BBC News https://www.bbc.com/indonesia/indonesia-57746385 diakses pada 21 Juli 2022
BBC News. (2021). Covid-19: Brazil to get fourth health minister since pandemic began. BBC News. https://www.bbc.com/news/world-latin-america-56410626 diakses pada 7 Juli 2022.
Bennouna et. al., C. (2021). Pandemic Policymaking in Presidential Federations: Explaining Subnational Responses to Covid-19 in Brazil, Mexico, and the United States. The Journal of Federalism, 51(4), 570-600.
Biller, D., & Savarese, M. (2020). Brazil cities lurch to lockdowns amid virus crisis red flags. Associated Press. https://apnews.com/article/public-health-health-rio-de-janeiro-ap-top-news-brazil-51e0ad7ee7d1ce702bdf887df466d047 diakses pada 10 Juli 2022.
Blofield, M., & Filgueira, F. (2020). COVID19 and Latin America: Social Impact, Policies and a Fiscal Case for an Emergency Social Protection Floor. Buenos Aires: CIPPEC.
Blofield, M., Hoffmann, B., & Llanos, M. (2020). Assessing the Political and Social Impact of the COVID-19 Crisis in Latin America. German Institute of Global and Area Studies (GIGA) Focus(3), 1-12.
Blofield, Merike., dan Hoffmann, Bert. (2020). Social Policy Responses to the COVID-19 Crisis and the Road Ahead. German Institute of Global and Area Studies. https://www.jstor.org/stable/resrep27045 diakses pada 30 Juni 2022 melalui
Boadle, A. (2021). Brazil Senate OKs easing budget cap to fund welfare program. Reuters. https://www.reuters.com/world/americas/brazil-senate-oks-easing-budget-cap-fund-welfare-program-2021-12-02/ diakses pada 23 Juli 2022.
Brito, R., & Ayres, M. (2020). Brazil's government backs new basic income payments to poor. Reuters. https://www.reuters.com/article/us-brazil-economics-idUSKBN26J381 diakses pada 24 Juli 2022
Cahyadi, I. R. (2020). Relawan Pendukung Gugus Tugas Bagikan Bansos untuk Warga Jabodetabek. Beritasatu https://www.beritasatu.com/kesehatan/639449/relawan-pendukung-gugus-tugas-bagikan-bansos-untuk-warga-jabodetabek diakses pada 18 Juli 2022
Carayannis, E. G., Samara, E. T., & Bakouros, Y. L. (2015). Innovation and entrepreneurship: theory, policy and practice. Springer.
Chaffin, B. C., H. Gosnell, and B. A. Cosens. (2014). A decade of adaptive governance scholarship: synthesis and future directions. Ecology and Society 19(3): 56
Cleaver, F., and L. Whaley. (2018). Understanding process, power, and meaning in adaptive governance: a critical institutional reading. Ecology and Society 23(2):49
CNN Indonesia. (2020). Kekacauan Bansos Corona, Masalah Klasik Big Data. https://www.cnnindonesia.com/nasional/20200508133813-20-501305/kekacauan-bansos-corona-masalah-klasik-big-data diakses pada 21 Juli 2022
CNN Indonesia. (2021). Pemda Dinilai 'Lelet' Salurkan Bansos. https://www.cnnindonesia.com/ekonomi/20210316142405-532-618103/pemda-dinilai-lelet-salurkan-bansos diakses pada 21 Juli 2022
Creswell, John., dan Poth, Cheril. (2018). Qualitative inquiry and research design: choosing among five approaches. London: SAGE
de Melo, M. C., Silva, A. G., Melo, R. A., & de Freitas, C. A. (2020). COVID-19 pandemic outbreak: the Brazilian reality from the first case to the collapse of health services. Anais da Academia Brasileira de Ciências | Annals of the Brazilian Academy of Sciences, 92(4), 1-14.
Dewi, S. R. (2020). Evaluasi Penyaluran Bantuan Sosial (Bansos) Tahap Satu, Covid-19. Ombudsman Republik Indonesia. https://ombudsman.go.id/artikel/r/artikel--evaluasi-penyaluran-bantuan-sosial-bansos-tahap-satu-covid-19- diakses pada 15 Juli 2022
Dang. (2022). COVID-19 in Viet Nam. New York: Routledge
DW. (2022). COVID pandemic pushes Germany to largest deficit since reunification. https://www.dw.com/en/covid-pandemic-pushes-germany-to-largest-deficit-since-reunification/a-57118164 diakses pada 23 Maret 2022
Firey, Thomas. (2020). Government in a Pandemic. Cato Institute, Policy Analysis No. 902. https://www.jstor.org/stable/resrep26889 diakses pada 30 Juni 2022
Fernandes, A., & Vargas, M. (2019, July 12). Governo vai reformular Bolsa Família e destinar benefício a jovens e crianças. UOL. https://economia.uol.com.br/noticias/estadao-conteudo/2019/12/07/governo-vai-reformular-bolsa-familia-e-destinar-beneficio-a-jovens-e-criancas.htm diakses pada 21 Juli 2022.
G1. (2020). 2,5 milhões receberam auxílio emergencial de R$ 600 nesta quinta. G1. https://g1.globo.com/economia/noticia/2020/04/09/6-milhoes-comecam-a-receber-auxilio-emergencial-de-r-600-nesta-quinta.ghtml diakses pada 9 Juli 2022
G1. (2021, December 25). Datafolha: brasileiro está dividido sobre substituição do Bolsa Família por Auxílio Brasil. G1. https://g1.globo.com/politica/noticia/2021/12/25/datafolha-brasileiro-esta-dividido-sobre-substituicao-do-bolsa-familia-por-auxilio-brasil.ghtml diakses pada 26 Juli 2022.
Gazola Hellman, A. (2015). How does Bolsa Família Work? Best Practices in the Implementation of Conditional Cash Transfer Programs in Latin America and the Caribbean. Inter-American Development Bank.
Gibson, John., Olivia, Susan. 2020. Direct and Indirect Effects of Covid-19 On Life Expectancy and Poverty in Indonesia. Jakarta: Bulletin of Indonesian Economic Studies.
Gosnell, H., Chaffin, B. C., Ruhl, J. B., Arnold, C. A., Craig, R. K., Benson, M. H., & Devenish, A. (2017). Transforming (perceived) rigidity in environmental law through adaptive governance. Ecology and Society, Vol. 22, No. 4.
Greer, Scott., King, Elizabeth., dan Fonseca, Elize. (2021). Coronavirus Politics: The Comparative Politics and Policy of COVID-19. Michigan: University of Michigan Press.
Greer et. al., S. (2021). Social policy as an integral component of pandemic response: Learning from COVID-19 in Brazil, Germany, India and the United States. Global Public Health, 16(8-9), 1209-1222.
Hermawati, I. & Risambessy, J. (2021). Asesmen Bantuan Sosial pada Masa Pandemi Covid-19 bagi Keluarga Miskin dan Rentan di Daerah Istimewa Yogyakarta. Jurnal PKS Vol 20 No 3 Desember 2021; 293 - 308
Hidayat, A.A. N. (2020). Penyaluran Bansos Lambat, Jokowi Minta 3 Menteri Ini Kerja Cepat. Tempo. https://bisnis.tempo.co/read/1343117/penyaluran-bansos-lambat-jokowi-minta-3-menteri-ini-kerja-cepat diakses pada 27 Juli 2022
Jarman, Holly. (2021). State Responses to the COVID-19 Pandemic: Governance, Surveillance, Coercion, and Social Policy. Michigan: University of Michigan Press.
Jeantet, D. (2021, November 18). Brazil swaps acclaimed welfare program for untested stand-in. Associated Press. https://apnews.com/article/business-brazil-jair-bolsonaro-rio-de-janeiro-85e900a6d9f66caacac082cb1b36b242 diakses pada 12 Juli 2022
KPMG. (2020, September 9). Brazil: Government and institution measures in response to COVID-19. KPMG. https://home.kpmg/xx/en/home/insights/2020/04/brazil-government-and-institution-measures-in-response-to-covid.html diakses pada 13 Juli 2022.
Laan, T., Roth, J., & Beedell, E. (2021). Nordic environmental fiscal reform. International Institute for Sustainable Development. https://www.iisd.org/publications/nordicenvironmental-fiscal-reform-post-pandemic-recovery diakses pada 27 Juli 2022
Lindert, K., Linder, A., Hobbs, J., & de la Brière, B. (2007, May). The Nuts and Bolts of Brazil’s Bolsa Família Program: Implementing Conditional Cash Transfers in a Decentralized Context. Social Protection Discussion Paper (709).
Marcello, M. C. (2021, November 26). Brazil's lower house approves replacement of Brazil's famed Bolsa Família. Reuters. https://www.reuters.com/world/americas/brazils-lower-house-approves-replacement-brazils-famed-bolsa-familia-2021-11-25/ diakses pada 25 Juli 2022
McCoy, T. L. (2016, October 4). As Brazil tilts rightward, Lula’s leftist legacy of lifting the poor is at risk. The Conversation. https://theconversation.com/as-brazil-tilts-rightward-lulas-leftist-legacy-of-lifting-the-poor-is-at-risk-65939 diakses pada 26 July 2022.
Mendez, Claudio. (2021). The Politics of the COVID-19 Pandemic Response In Chile. Michigan: University of Michigan Press.
Mufida, A. (2020). Polemik Pemberian Bantuan Sosial Di Tengah Pandemic Covid-19. ADALAH: Buletin Hukum & Keadilan, 4(1), p.159–166
Murphy, Mary. (2021). A New Welfare Imaginary for the Island of Ireland. Irish Studies in International Affairs, Vol. 32, No. 2.
Negara. (2022). COVID-19 Impacts and Recovery: Lessons Learned from Singapore. New York: Routledge.
Noerkaisar, Noni. (2021). Efektivitas Penyaluran Bantuan Sosial Pemerintah Untuk Mengatasi Dampak Covid-19 di Indonesia. JEL Classification, N4, N9, 83-104.
Novrizaldi. (2020). Tahap 2 Penyaluran JPS, Pemerintah Tambahkan Program Bantuan Beras dan Bantuan Uang Tunai. Kemenko PMK. https://www.kemenkopmk.go.id/tahap-2-penyaluran-jps-pemerintah-tambahkan-program-bantuan-beras-dan-bantuan-uang-tunai diakses pada 25 Juli 2022
Nugent, C. (2022). Lula Talks to TIME About Ukraine, Bolsonaro, and Brazil's Fragile Democracy. TIME. https://time.com/6173232/lula-da-silva-transcript/ diakses pada 27 Juli 2022.
O Sul. (2019). O presidente Bolsonaro criou o 13º salário do Bolsa Família. O Sul. https://www.osul.com.br/o-presidente-bolsonaro-criou-o-13o-salario-do-bolsa-familia/ diakses pada 25 Juli, 2022.
Olivia, Susan., Gibson, John., Nasrudin Rus’an. 2020. Indonesia in the Time of Covid-19. Jakarta: Bulletin of Indonesian Economic Studies.
Ozcurumez, Saime. (2021). COVID-19 In Turkey: Public Health Centralism. Michigan: University of Michigan Press.
Paraguassu, L. (2020, May 6). Major Brazilian cities set lockdowns as virus spreads. Reuters. https://www.reuters.com/article/us-health-coronavirus-brazil-lockdown-idUSKBN22H2V3 diakses pada 10 Juli 2022.
Romer, Christina., dan Rome, David. (2022). A Social Insurance Perspective on Pandemic Fiscal Policy. The Journal of Economic Perspectives, Vol. 36, No.2.
RSSEE SG. (2020). The Western Balkan Countries in the Face of the COVID-19 Pandemic. Connections QJ, Vol. 19, No. 2.
Resende, T. (2019, October 1). Bolsa Família volta a ter fila de espera e corre risco de encolher. Folha de S.Paulo. https://www1.folha.uol.com.br/mercado/2019/10/bolsa-familia-volta-a-ter-fila-de-espera-e-corre-risco-de-encolher.shtml diakses pada 24 July 2022.
Schulze. (2022). Policy Responses to the COVID-19 Pandemic: The Case of Germany. New York: Routledge.
Setiawan, R. (2021). Sengkarut Data Bansos COVID yang Berimbas Penundaan hingga Pungli. Tirto. https://tirto.id/gilN diakses pada 23 Juli 2022
Sugiarto, E.C. (2020). Menjaga Momentum Pemulihan Ekonomi. Setkab. https://setkab.go.id/menjaga-momentum-pemulihan-ekonomi/ diakses pada 24 Juli 2022
Suryahadi, Asep., Al Izzati, Ridho., Suryadarma, Daniel. 2020. Estimating the Impact of Covid-19 on Poverty in Indonesia. Jakarta: Bulletin of Indonesian Economic Studies.
Temoteo, A., & Araújo, C. (2020, October 23). Governo Bolsonaro não deve pagar 13º salário do Bolsa Família em 2020. UOL. https://economia.uol.com.br/noticias/redacao/2020/10/23/bolsa-familia-governo-bolsonaro-pagamento.htm dipetik pada 24 Juli 2022.
The Economist. (2020). Bolsa Família, Brazil’s admired anti-poverty programme, is flailing. The Economist. https://www.economist.com/the-americas/2020/01/30/bolsa-familia-brazils-admired-anti-poverty-programme-is-flailing diakses pada 24 Juli 2022
The World Bank Group. (2020). World Bank approves loan supporting the expansion of the Bolsa Família Program. The World Bank. https://www.worldbank.org/en/news/press-release/2020/10/29/world-bank-approves-loan-supporting-expansion-of-bolsa-familia-program diakses pada 26 Juli 2022
UNCTAD. (2022). China’s structural transformation: what can developing countries learn? UNCTAD.https://unctad.org/webflyer/chinas-structural-transformation-what-can-developing-countries-learn diakses pada 10 Mei 2022
UNCTAD. (2020). South-South Cooperation at the time of COVID-19: Building Solidarity Among Developing Countries. UNCTAD. https://unctad.org/system/files/official-document/gdsinf2020d4_en.pdf diakses pada 27 Juli 2022
WHO. (2020). Preventing and Managing COVID-19 Across Long-term Care Services. WHO. https://www.jstor.org/stable/resrep27994.6 diakses pada 30 Juni 2022
Van Buuren, A., A. M. Keessen, C. Van Leeuwen, J. Eshuis, and G. J. Ellen. (2015). Implementation arrangements for climate adaptation in the Netherlands: characteristics and underlying mechanisms of adaptive governance. Ecology and Society 20(4):11
Victoria, A. O. (2020). Sri Mulyani Keluhkan Data Masih Hambat Penyaluran Bansos Rp 81 Triliun. Katadata. https://katadata.co.id/agustiyanti/finansial/5fac5200590a1/sri-mulyani-keluhkan-data-masih-hambat-penyaluran-bansos-rp-81-triliun diakses pada 25 Juli 2022
Yunita, I. & Agustang, A. (2021). Ketidakmerataan Bantuan Langsung Tunai Di Masa Pandemi Covid-19 Pada Masyarakat Kurang Mampu di Desa Carawali Kabupaten Sidrap. Pinisi Journal Of Sociology Education Review; Vol. 1; No. 2; Juli 2021, p.181-191. http://103.76.50.195/jser/article/view/22208