# Methods to Determine Ductility of Structural Members: A Review

### Abstract

Ductility plays a crucial role in ensuring the safety of a structure, as its inadequacy can lead to sudden and brittle failure. Despite its significance, there is no explicit method for determining, leading to inconsistency and confusion in selecting appropriate techniques. Misjudging a structure’s ductile behaviour can have catastrophic consequences. Therefore, this study examined several preliminary studies and identified twenty-one methods for computing ductility indices. These indices were categorized into three types, namely conventional, displacement-based, and energy-based. The conventional ductility indices are commonly applied to steel-reinforced members, deformation-based ductility indices to FRP-reinforced members, and energy-based ductility indices to earthquake-resistant and static-load structures. Conventional ductility indices are specific to ductile reinforcements, while displacement-based and energy-based ductility indices apply to both ductile and non-ductile reinforcements. However, different calculation methods can lead to significant variations in the computed ductility, particularly for those involving the first crack, and load factor, thereby leading to different ductility requirements for ensuring structural safety. Additionally, not all methods are explicit, and it is crucial to avoid indiscriminately applying requirements from one method to another.

### References

ASTM International, 2011. ASTM E2126 – 11 Standard Test Methods for Cyclic (Reversed) Load Test for Shear Resistance of Vertical Elements of the Lateral Force Resisting Systems for Buildings.

Abdelraham A. A., Tadros, G. & Rizkalla, S. H., 1995. Test Model for the First Canadian Smart Highway Bridge. ACI Structural Journal, 92.

ACI-318-19 2019. Building Code Requirements for Structural Concrete and Commentary. Farmington Hills MI: American Concrete Institute.

ACI Committee 440, 2015. Guide for the Design and Construction of Structural Concrete Reinforced with Fiber-Reinforced Polymer (FRP) Bars. American Concrete Institute.

Alsayed, S. H. & Alhozaimy, A. M., 1999. Ductility of Concrete Beams Reinforced with FRP Bars and Steel Fibers. Journal of Composite Materials, 33, pp. 1792-1806.

Antonius, S. & Imran, I., 2012. Experimental Study of Confined Low-, Medium- and High-Strength Concrete Subjected to Concentric Compression. Journal of Engineering and Technological Sciences, 44(3), pp. 252-269.

Ashour, S. A., 2000. Effect of Compressive Strength and Tensile Reinforcement Ratio on Flexural Behavior of High-Strength Concrete Beams. Engineering Structures, 22, pp. 413-423.

Bakht, B., Al-Bazi, G., Banthia, N., Cheung, M., Erki, M. A., Faoro, M., Machida, A., Mufti, A. A., Neale, K. W. & Tadros, G., 2000. Canadian Bridge Design Code Provisions for Fiber-Reinforced Structures. Journal of Composites for Construction, 4, pp. 3-15.

Barrera, A. C., Bonet, J. L., Romero, M. L. & Fernández, M. A., 2012. Ductility of Slender Reinforced Concrete Columns under Monotonic Flexure and Constant Axial Load. Engineering Structures, 40, pp. 398-412.

BS-EN 1992-1-1, 2004. Eurocode 2: Design of concrete structures - Part 1-1: General rules and rules for buildings. British Standard,

CAN/CSA-S6-06, 2006. Canadian Highway Bridge Design Code. Canadian Standards Association.

Chen, C.-C. & Sudibyo, T., 2018. Effect of Intermediate Stiffeners on the Behaviors of Partially Concrete Encased Steel Beams. Advances in Civil Engineering, 8672357.

Dancygier, A. N. & Berkover, E., 2016. Cracking Localization and Reduced Ductility in Fiber-Reinforced Concrete Beams with Low Reinforcement Ratios. Engineering Structures, 111, pp. 411-424.

Dolan, C. W., Hamilton III, H. R., Bakis, C. E. & Nanni, A., 2001. Design Recommendations for Concrete Structures Prestressed With FRP Tendons. FHWA Contract DTFH61-96-C-00019:

El Zareef, M. A. & El Madawy, M. E., 2018. Effect of Glass-Fiber Rods on the Ductile Behaviour of Reinforced Concrete Beams. Alexandria Engineering Journal, 57, pp. 4071-4079.

Fu, C., Zhu, Y. & Wang, Y., 2020. Stiffness Assessment of Cracked Post-Tensioned Concrete Beams with Unbonded Tendons Based on The Cracking Pattern. Engineering Structures, 214, 110599.

Ghallab, A., 2014. Ductility of Externally Prestressed Continuous Concrete Beams. KSCE Journal of Civil Engineering, 18, pp. 595-606.

Grace, N. F., Soliman, A. K., Abdel-Sayed, G. & Saleh, K. R., 1998. Behavior and Ductility of Simple and Continuous FRP Reinforced Beams. Journal of Composites for Construction, 2, pp. 186-194.

Hason, M. M., Hanoon, A. N., Saleem, S. J., Hejazi F., & Al Zand, A. W., 2021. Characteristics of Experimental Ductility Energy Index of Hybrid-CFRP Reinforced Concrete Deep Beams. SN Applied Sciences, 3, 200.

Hassan, N. Z., Ismael, H. M. & Salman, A. M., 2018. Study Behavior of Hollow Reinforced Concrete Beams. International Journal of Current Engineering and Technology, 8, 1640-1651.

Jaeger, L. G., Muftu, A. & Tadros, G., 1997. The Concept of the Overall Performance Factor in Rectangular Section Reinforced Concrete Beam. Proceeding of 3rd International Symposium on Non-metallic (FRP) Reinforcement for Concrete Structures, Tokyo, 551-558.

Jang, I. Y., Park, H. G., Kim, S. S., Kim, J. H. & Kim, Y. G., 2008. On the Ductility of High-Strength Concrete Beams. International Journal of Concrete Structures and Materials, 2, pp. 115-122.

Kwan, A. K. H., Ho, J. C. M. & Pam, H. J., 2002. Flexural Strength and Ductility of Reinforced Concrete Beams. Proceedings of the Institution of Civil Engineers - Structures and Buildings, 152, pp. 361-369.

Lim, Y. T., Ling, J. H., Lau, J. W. & Yik, A. Y. M., 2021. Experimental Study on the Flexural Behavior of Reinforced Polystyrene Blocks in Concrete Beams. Journal of the Civil Engineering Forum, 7, 197-208.

Ling, J. H., Tang, H. S., Leong, W. K. & Sia, H. T., 2019. Effects of Transverse Circular Opening in Reinforced Concrete Beam Subjected to Incremental Static Load. Borneo Journal of Sciences and Technology, 1, pp. 39-44.

Macchi, G., Pinto, P. E. & Sanpaolesi, L., 1996. Ductility Requirements for Reinforcement under Eurocodes. Structural Engineering International, 6, pp. 249-254.

Manisekar, R., 2015. Ductility of Concrete Members Partially Prestressed with Unbonded and External Tendons. Advances in Structural Engineering.

Mufti, A. A., Newhook, J. & Tadros, G. S., 1996. Deformability versus Ductility in Concrete Beams with FRP Reinforcement. Proceedings of The 2nd International Conference on Advanced Composite Materials in Bridges and Structures, Montreal.

Muralidhara Rao, T., Srikar, N., Sukesh Reddy, G. & Praveen, B., 2015. Ductility of Reinforced Concrete Beams. CVR Journal of Science and Technology, 9, pp. 7-12.

Naaman, A. E., 1985. Partially Prestressed Concrete: Review and Recommendations. PCI Journal, 30, pp. 31–71.

Naaman, A. E., 2003. FRP Reinforcements in Structural Concrete: Assessment, Progress and Prospects. Fibre-Reinforced Polymer Reinforcement for Concrete Structures FRPRCS-6, Singapore.

Naaman, A. E. & Jeong, S. M., 1995. Structural Ductility of Concrete Beams Prestressed with FRP. Non-Metallic (FRP) Reinforcement for Concrete Structures Proceedings of the Second International RILEM Symposium, London. pp. 379–386.

New Zealand Standard, 2006. NZS 3101.1:2006 New Zealand Standard Concrete structures standard. Part 1: The design of concrete structures.

Nie, J. G., Hu, H. S. & Eatherton, M. R., 2014. Concrete Filled Steel Plate Composite Coupling Beams: Experimental Study. Journal of Constructional Steel Research, 94, pp. 49-63.

Nogueira, C. G. & Rodrigues, I. D., 2017. Ductility Analysis of RC Beams Considering the Concrete Confinement Effect Produced by the Shear Reinforcement: a Numerical Approach. Latin American Journal of Solids and Structures, 14, pp. 2342-2372.

Oudah, F. & El-Hacha, R. 2012. A New Ductility Model of Reinforced Concrete Beams Strengthened using Fiber Reinforced Polymer Reinforcement. Composites Part B: Engineering, 43, pp. 3338-3347.

Pam, H. J., Kwan, A. K. H. & Islam, M. S., 2001. Flexural Strength and Ductility of Reinforced Normal- and High-Strength Concrete Beams. Proceedings of the Institution of Civil Engineers - Structures and Buildings, 146, pp. 381-389.

Pan, A. & Moehle, J. P., 1989. Lateral Displacement Ductility of Reinforced Concrete Flat Plates. ACI Structural Journal, 21, pp. 250-258.

Park, R., 1988. Ductility Evaluation from Laboratory and Analytical Testing. The 9th world conference on earthquake engineering, Tokyo-Kyoto, Japan. pp. 605-616.

Paultre, P. & Légeron, F., 2008. Confinement Reinforcement Design for Reinforced Concrete Columns. Journal of Structural Engineering, 134, pp. 738-749.

Rakhshanimehr, M., Esfahani, M. R., Kianoush, M. R., Mohammadzadeh, B. A. & Mousavi, S. R., 2014. Flexural Ductility of Reinforced Concrete Beams with Lap-Spliced Bars. Canadian Journal of Civil Engineering, 41, pp. 594-604.

Soudki, K. A., 1994. Behaviour of Horizontal Connections for Precast Concrete Load-bearing Shear Wall Panels Subjected to reversed Cyclic Deformations. PhD, University of Manitoba.

Soudki, K. A., Rizkalla, S. H. & Leblanc, B., 1995. Horizontal Connections for Precast Concrete Shear Wall Subjected to Cyclic Deformations Part 1: Mild Steel Connections. PCI Journal, 40, pp. 78-96.

Spadea, G., Bencardino, F. & Swamy, R. N., 1997. Strengthening and Upgrading Structures with Bonded CFRP Sheets Design Aspects for Structural Integrity, Proceedings of Third International RILEM Symposium (FRPRCS-3): Non-Metallic (FRP) for Concrete Structures, Sapporo, Japan. pp. 379-386.

Spadea, G., Swamy, R. N. & Bencardino, F., 2001. Strength and Ductility of RC Beams Repaired with Bonded CFRP Laminates. Journal of Bridge Engineering, 6, pp. 349-355.

Tann, D. B., Delpak, R. & Davies, P., 2004. Ductility and Deformability of Fibre-Reinforced Polymer-Strengthened Reinforced Concrete Beams. Proceedings of the Institution of Civil Engineers - Structures and Buildings, 157, pp. 19-30.

Teixeira, M. M. & Bernardo, L. F. A., 2018. Ductility of RC Beams under Torsion. Engineering Structures, 168, pp. 759-769.

Thériault, M. & Benmokrane, B., 1998. Effects of FRP Reinforcement Ratio and Concrete Strength on Flexural Behavior of Concrete Beams. Journal of Composites for Construction, 2, pp. 7-16.

Thomsen, H., Spacone, E., Limkatanyu, S. & Camata, G., 2004. Failure Mode Analyses of Reinforced Concrete Beams Strengthened in Flexure with Externally Bonded Fiber-Reinforced Polymers. Journal of Composites for Construction, 8, pp. 123-131.

Wang, H. & Belarbi, A., 2011. Ductility Characteristics of Fiber-Reinforced-Concrete Beams Reinforced with FRP Rebars. Construction and Building Materials, 25, pp. 2391-2401.

Wang, X., Chen, Z., Ding, L., Shi, Y., Zhu, Z. & Wu, Z., 2021. Long-Term Flexural Behavior of Concrete Beams with Hybrid FRP and Steel Reinforcements in Simulated Marine Environment. Structures, 33, pp. 4556-4567.

Wu, Y. F., 2006. New Avenue of Achieving Ductility for Reinforced Concrete Members. Journal of Structural Engineering, 132, pp. 1502-1506.

Zou, P. X. W., 2003. Flexural Behavior and Deformability of Fiber Reinforced Polymer Prestressed Concrete Beams. Journal of Composites for Construction, 7, pp. 275-284.

*Journal of the Civil Engineering Forum*,

*9*(2), 181-194. https://doi.org/10.22146/jcef.6631

Copyright (c) 2023 The Author(s)

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 4.0 International License.

Copyright is granted to authors for the purpose of providing protection for articles written to describe experiments and their results. JCEF will protect and defend the work and reputation of the author and are also willing to address any allegations of violation, plagiarism, fraud, etc. against articles written and published by JCEF. JCEF is published under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 4.0 International License (CC BY-SA 4.0). The author holds the copyright and assigns the journal rights to the first publication (online and print) of the work simultaneously.